 |
| Things looking ugly for MJD |
FIRST THREE ROUNDS: Its been a couple weeks since my blog about the first round of fantasy football draft, and a couple things have changed my rankings on the first round. Maurice Jones-Drew who I had ranked sixth last time I ranked my top twelve has continued to hold out, and I am starting to get worried. I don't think MJD will miss any games, but ala Chris Johnson last year I could see a drop in production from Drew. I don't think he will have anywhere near the drop off that Chris Johnson had, however I think his output will lessen. Jones-Drew is going to fall down to #12 on my rankings making him a borderline first or second round pick depending on your league size.
Another top-twelve running back that is moving down is Ryan Mathews. On Mathews first carry, repeat,
first carry Mathews suffered a broken collarbone that is supposed to keep him out 4-6 weeks. Reports are saying that Mathews will probably miss 1-3 weeks and at the latest will be available by week four. I think he will probably miss week one and two, but he'll be available by week three. I have no reasoning for that, but I think it's a conservative prediction of what fantasy owners can expect from him. Mathews does not just drop in my rankings because he'll miss a couple games, but also because this injury just reinforces to me how injury prone he is. Mathews has played 12 and 14 games in his two respective seasons so far, and has been hampered in many other games he played. After this injury I expect nothing else from Mathews this year, but he has more upside than last year because he has less backfield competition. Without Mike Tolbert stealing touchdowns from Mathews I think he will do slightly better in games which he is fully healthy, but he will not always be healthy. Due to his injury I drop Mathews from 12th to 16th on my overall rankings.
 |
| Charles is looking to bounce back from ACL surgery |
My top twelve obviously did a little shuffling because of the movement of Mathews and Jones-Drew. Drew Brees moved up to 6th overall replacing Mathews, but everyone else didn't just move up. The trio of Calvin Johnson, Matt Forte, and Chris Johnson got shuffled up this time around. I decided that both Forte and Chris Johnson should leapfrog Johnson for the 7th and 8th overall spots respectively. My decision was made because in my opinion Forte has a slightly higher upside than Calvin, and has an equal amount of downside. Chris versus Calvin was much tougher to decide because Chris has much more upside, but also a significant amount of downside. My decision was made based on how deep wide receiver is compared to the weakness of the running back position. Ultimately I decided it was a better investment to go after a high end running back than receiver. So Calvin Johnson moved to #9 on the overall rankings leaving his quarterback Matthew Stafford right behind him at #10. Last year Stafford and Johnson finished in those exact spots in overall VBD, and I think they both will have similar seasons. At #11 Jamaal Charles jumped into my rankings after not even being talked about in my last blog. The word out of training camp was that Jamal Charles had regained his burst and looked good in drills after coming off his ACL surgery. Both Jones-Drew and Marshawn Lynch are very close to Charles in my rankings, but I decided upon Charles at #11, MJD at #12 and Lynch at #13. In my opinion Charles has more upside than Lynch, and also has slightly less downside surprisingly. Though Charles is coming off surgery, Lynch has proven that he can be awful, while Charles should not be hampered by the ACL too much. Charles and Jones-Drew are very similar because they both could miss a game at the beginning of the season, but I don't think either will. They're also very similar because their best seasons had them each finish 3rd overall at running back, but because Charles is younger I think he has a better chance of repeating that which gives him more upside.
 |
| Battle of the TE's: Graham versus Gronkowski |
After Lynch at #13 comes the raging debate of Jimmy Graham versus Rob Gronkowski. In my first round blog I talked about Gronk as a potential first rounder, but not Graham. The reasoning for that was that Gronk's year last year was 11th in overall VBD for ten team leagues while Graham's was 21st. However this year I think they will both settle somewhere in between. Gronk has much more downside than Graham because his touchdowns are not necessarily repeatable, and their are a lot more options in the New England offense. Gronkowski's upside however is only slightly better because I don't really think Gronk will ever be better numbers wise than last year, but he could do about the same thing. Graham could do better than last year this year because he has only been playing high-level football for a couple years and there is more room for growth. I also could see Graham getting more targets because the Saints lost Robert Meachem, and with the lack of Sean Payton I could see Brees relying on his security blanket in Graham more. Graham doesn't have much downside except for defenses keying on him and Sean Payton not being there, but I don't think either should really effect him. Overall Gronk has a slightly higher upside, but a much bigger downside making Graham #14 overall and Gronk #15.
 |
| Julio Jones or Roddy White? (Hint: Rhymes with Bones) |
In my opinion players 1-6 overall (Aaron Rodgers, Ray Rice, Arian Foster, Tom Brady, Lesean McCoy, and Drew Brees respectively) are a clear cut above the rest and make up "tier 1." Tier 2 in my opinion is players 7-15 that have been discussed in these last couple paragraphs. Everyone in the 7-15 range either has a ton of upside and a good amount of downside (Chris Johnson, Jamaal Charles, Maurice Jones-Drew, Marshawn Lynch, and Rob Gronkowski), or good not great upside, and not much downside (Matt Forte, Calvin Johnson, Matthew Stafford, and Jimmy Graham). At #16 I have Ryan Mathews starting tier 3. Mathews has the talent to be a top-ten player, but not the durability to be a top-ten pick. Tier 3 is filled with players just like Mathews, talent, but at the same time a lot of question marks. For me Mathews, Cam Newton, Larry Fitzgerald, Darren McFadden, Brandon Marshall, Demarco Murray, Steven Jackson, Roddy White, Wes Welker, A.J. Green, Adrian Peterson, Trent Richardson, Percy Harvin, and Julio Jones make up the next tier. After Mathews I have Cam Newton at #17 because he has such a high upside. In my opinion Cam Newton is one of two players in this tier who have the best shot at ending up as a top 5 overall VBD ranker by season end. The other is Adrian Peterson, and while both Cam and AP have a lot of question marks Peterson has more worrisome ones that drop him further down my rankings. At #18 I have the much safer pick in Larry Fitzgerald. I do not think Fitz will finish the season as a top 20 player, but I also don't think he'll be worse than 30th and because of that he earns a top 20 ranking. Darren McFadden and his immense potential slot in at #19 for me, and if you draft him you can do nothing but cross your fingers and hope he doesn't get injured. Rounding out the top 20 is Julio Jones of the Atlanta Falcons. If Jones manages to play 14 games I truly believe he will be a top 15 fantasy player, and I think he is the second most likely WR behind Calvin Johnson to have a top-ten fantasy year. However due to his injury risk I put him at #20 overall.
 |
| Not quite sure what the defenders doing |
21st is Greg Jennings who is similar to Larry Fitzgerald in that he doesn't have a ton of upside, but when your a primary target on the team that has Aaron Rodgers you also don't have much downside. At #22 I put Roddy White who lines up across the field from #20 Julio Jones. White doesn't have the upside of Jones, but he also doesn't have the downside which makes him a great pick at WR. 23rd overall I have Steven Jackson. Jackson is not a flashy player who's going to have a massive year, but he's the only running back and really the only talent on a weak Rams offense. Jackson's upside is around 18th overall, but his downside isn't below 30th and he is a good safe pick. At 24th overall I have A.J. Green of the Cincinnati Bengals. The best thing about Green is that he is far and away the best option on his team. The worst thing about Green is that he is far and away the best option on his team, and he has Andy Dalton throwing to him. Defenses will definitely key on Green this year, and I'm not sure Dalton is talented enough to still get Green the ball while making the defense pay by hitting other options. Nonetheless Green is an extremely athletic, young talented wide receiver who is pretty safe to put up good numbers, and has the potential for great ones. In a 12 team league two rounds should be wrapped up after 24 picks, and I make sure I get two of my personal top 24 regardless of position (the only thing I wouldn't do is draft two QB's).
 |
| I'm not sure if Peterson's able to play "All Day" |
25th for me is Adrian Peterson coming off his late season ACL surgery. This ranking is in constant flux for me, and reports leading up to week 1 will most certainly change my ranking of him. If he manages to play 13 games at close to full strength I still think he is worth a high pick because that's just as good as #13 overall Marshawn Lynch at full strength. However I'm not sure he'll be close to full strength, and frankly I have no idea where to rank him. If your drafting soon I wouldn't take AP if there were comparable options on the board, but I think by the end of the month late drafters like myself will be able to better gauge where to take Peterson. Brandon Marshall signed with the Chicago Bears this off season, and that alone is why I rank Marshall so highly. Marshall's peak came when Jay Cutler was his quarterback with Denver, and now Cutler is his QB in Chicago. Marshall has been playing with the crap sandwich more commonly known as Matt Moore, Chad Henne, Chad Pennington, and Tyler Thigpen these past couple years so his production should improve greatly. I put Cowboys Running Back Demarco Murray at 27th overall. Murray is recovering from an ACL tear he suffered last season. Murray shouldn't miss more than one or two games, and he could miss zero but everyone wants to know if he'll be at full strength. If he is at full strength the question remains whether he can stay healthy, but in limited action last year he proved when healthy he is a dynamic running back that plays very similar to Adrian Peterson. There are a ton of questions with Murray, but with such a weak running back field his upside makes him a top 30 draft pick.
 |
| No this is not the same person as the picture above |
In my opinion the three most underrated top 30 talents are Matt Forte, Julio Jones, and Percy Harvin who I rank 28th overall. In 6 of Harvin's last 7 games in 2012 he had 15 or more points, and he was
the only wide receiver to do so. If you project that over a 16 game season Harvin would have been fantasy's second best receiver with only 4 points less than Calvin Johnson. Harvin's crazy production came while Peterson was either out or hampered by injury, and the beginning of this year should be just the same for Harvin. Once Peterson recovers fully Harvin probably won't get as many touches, but he should continue to be very productive. Wes Welker ranks 29th overall despite finishing as the third best receiver in fantasy last year. The reason Welker drops so much is because the Patriots added Brandon Lloyd. With Gronkowski, Aaron Hernandez, and Lloyd competing for targets I think Welker will continue to be productive, but not as productive. Finishing off the top 30 is rookie running back Trent Richardson of the Cleveland Browns. Richardson suffered an injury in training camp, but it doesn't look to severe so he shouldn't miss any time. It's hard to rank Richardson because he is a rookie who is going to play on one of the worst offenses in football. Normally fantasy owners try to avoid the words "rookie" worst offense" "Cleveland" and "Browns" so this is surely a sign of the Mayans being correct. However Richardson is a great talent who really is the only option on this Browns team meaning that the volume of his work should make up for the fact that defenses will pay so much attention to him. That's the top 30 so in a ten-team league (and even in a 12) you should aim to get three of these thirty players (or three of your own top 30) as long as you don't have to get two tight ends or two quarterbacks.
GENERAL STRATEGY BY POSITION
QB
 |
| Is Eli really better than me? |
The top five quarterbacks this year are stronger than any year in recent history and arguably ever. All five of them are worthy of either a first or second round pick, and Aaron Rodgers is worth the #1 overall pick. If you don't get one of those five guys the only other quarterback who has that type of talent is Michael Vick. Vick is worth a mid 4th round pick in my opinion, but after that it's best to wait. Currently in ESPN live drafts Eli Manning is going 31st, Peyton Manning 42nd, Tony Romo 48, Phillip Rivers 60. This makes no sense to me, and I think Rivers is just as good as either Manning. If I'm drafting a quarterback other than those top guys I'm waiting till the 6th round and grabbing Rivers. Of the top ten QB's Peyton and Vick are the only ones I would draft a backup for. Vick because of his injury history, and Peyton because of the uncertainty surrounding him. Matt Ryan is also a fine starter if your in a deeper league. Peyton is a big risk so I'd actually rather take Ryan as my starting QB. If your getting a backup QB Robert Griffin III is obviously the most exciting, but if you want to get him make sure you don't reach for him. I wouldn't draft a backup like RG3 until the 9th round at earliest, but I'd prefer just not to draft a backup QB. In drafts I'm in I'm always going to try and get one of the elite five quarterbacks earlier on, and not draft a backup.
RB
 |
| Boy does this team need a "law-firm" |
Running Back is incredibly weak this year and your goal should be to get as many as you can. Hopefully you'll get one elite running back in the first three rounds, and after that just load up on running backs. Wide Receiver is super deep so in rounds 4-7 you should be drafting at least two more running backs and more if you didn't get any early on. You should end up with at least six running backs by the end of your draft. If all goes well you want three running backs who you feel comfortable starting and another three or four who have potential. When drafting running backs in the later rounds the key is to look for talent and opportunity. You don't need both, but if you can that's the priority. In the middle rounds look for players who have been undervalued. One of my favorite steals for this draft is Benjarvus Green-Ellis. Cincinnati is a team that likes to run the ball, and Green-Ellis is the type of powerful running back that can handle a lot of carries. He's not the most explosive and shifty running back, but he grinds out yards and gets in the end zone. Every year multiple running backs have breakout years so when drafting you should be looking for players who have that potential. Overall, I want to get as many running backs as possible, and hope to get one guy who breaks out.
 |
| Lloyd: "So this is what a real throw feels like." |
WR
Wide Receiver is super deep. Just like running back I want to get one elite wide receiver, but unlike running back you have more elite options. In the middle rounds you should mostly focus on running back, but by round 8 you should have at least 2 quality wide receivers. In rounds 8-11 you can get surprisingly good wide receiver talent, and you should grab a couple here. By the end of the draft you should have 5 or 6 wide receivers, and 2 or 3 of them being good starting/flex options. In the middle rounds a good WR to grab is Brandon Lloyd. Lloyd isn't going to get a ton of targets in the loaded patriots offense, but he will be dynamic nonetheless. With Josh McDaniels as his offensive coordinator he should get a lot of deep looks from Tom Brady and could very easily have an 1,000 yard 10 touchdown year. Lloyd could have a Randy Moss like year for the patriots, and at the very least he's a good flex play at WR. In late rounds there is a lot of good talents like Reuben Randle, Titus Young, Vincent Brown, and Torrey Smith available for the taking. Wide Receiver is the one position that is so deep it is hard not to leave the draft feeling like you picked well. My one word of caution is that you don't forget to grab quality running backs because you want to take all the good WR's in the mid rounds. Just be patient my friend.
TE
 |
| I'm coming for you Vernon |
Graham and Gronkowski are both worth 2nd round picks. If you don't get one of them, and don't feel like you need to get one of them, just wait. Antonio Gates and Vernon Davis are going around 50th overall right now while Tony Gonzalez, Fred Davis, and Brandon Pettigrew are going 90th to 110th. I legitimately feel that Vernon Davis is no better than any of those three and Gates is a major health concern. If I don't get one of the top guys I'm getting Davis, Gonzalez, Pettigrew, Jacob Tamme, or Jared Cook in the 10th round or later and feeling good about it. I like Graham and Gronk, but truthfully if you end up Fred Davis and a elite RB/WR I'm just as if not more happy than getting Gronk and a mediocre WR or low end RB. Fred Davis is in my opinion considerably better than Vernon Davis (from a fantasy perspective), and I am going after him if I don't get one of the top tight ends.
DEFENSE AND KICKER
A defense should be taken in the 15th round and a Kicker in the 16th. There are no exceptions whatsoever, and it is absolutely ridiculous to do anything else. Defenses are best if used on a week by week basis, and different kickers have good fantasy seasons every year. There is no logical argument that a defense or kicker should be taken any earlier, and you should be stockpiling running backs and wide receivers. (Defenses and Kickers are so pointless I'm not even going to give them a picture)
ENDING TEAM
Your team should end up looking something like this: 1 Quarterback (unless you have Peyton or Vick), 7/6 Running Backs, 6/5 Wide Receivers, 1 Tight End (unless you have Gates), 1 Defense, 1 Kicker (if you think drafting Defense and Kickers is bad before the sixteenth, you can't even comprehend the concept of drafting a backup). If you follow this strategy your team should be in pretty good shape. I don't rank a full 200 players, but ESPN has some great resources and cheat sheets. After the first 3 or 4 rounds I usually refer to analyst Matthew Berry's rankings, and I think his are the best available(they can be found on ESPN.com). Feel free to use my top 30 rankings, in fact I'd feel very flattered if you did, but I do think making your own rankings is the best option there is.